Still working on the name spellings for each. We have Joseph as the son of a different Benjamin Balay married to Anna Pierce as his mother. Joseph's sister Catharine was married to James Carroll. (the brother of Joseph's wife Elizabeth) Joseph and Elizabeth had a son William Nelson Perry born abt 1838 married to a Elizabeth Perry February 4, 1862 in Morgan County,IN Descendants of Benjamin Balay

1 Benjamin Balay Born: 1786 in Virginia Died: in Kentucky
.. +Anna Pierce Born: 1786 in North Carolina
........ 2 Joseph H. Balay Born: 1802 in Tennessee
............ +Elizabeth Carroll Born: March 09, 1807 in Illinois Died: May 14, 1883 in Morgan County, Indiana Father: Bartholomew Carroll Mother: Frances Clark
........ 2 Dorcas Bailey Born: 1805 in Kentucky Died: Bef. 1860 in Morgan County,Indiana
............ +Walker Ennis Born: 1807 in Kentucky Married: November 30, 1828 in Morgan County, Indiana Father: William Ennis Mother: Catherine Pointer
........ 2 Tilford Bailey Born: February 09, 1807 in Kentucky Died: March 22, 1871 in Hendricks County, Indiana
............ +Matilda Huffman Born: 1810 in Kentucky Married: May 19, 1830 in Morgan County, Indiana
........ 2 Catherine Bailey Born: December 01, 1811 in Green County, Kentucky Died: February 22, 1888 in Shelby County, Missouri
............ +James Carroll Born: January 08, 1808 in Kentucky Died: November 29, 1872 in Shelby County, Missouri Married: in Indiana Father: Bartholomew Carroll Mother: Frances Clark
........ 2 Amos Bailey Born: August 22, 1814 in Kentucky Died: September 09, 1876 in Oblong, Crawford County, Illinois
............ +Mary Clendenen Born: 1817 in Kentucky Died: March 17, 1864 in Martinsville, Morgan County, Indiana Married: November 10, 1836 in Morgan County, Indiana
........ 2 Benjamin C. Bailey Born: July 24, 1821 in Kentucky Died: March 25, 1906 in Morgan County , Indiana
............ +Rebecca Persinger Born: June 14, 1828 in Ohio Died: December 12, 1912 in Morgan County , Indiana Married: January 19, 1847 in Morgan County , Indiana