1870 Census, Newton, Trumbull, Ohio
Hill, John, 49, b. Penn, hotel keeper
-, Elizabeth, 44, b. Ohio [nee Loveless, m1. William R. Selby]
-, Mary, 12, b. Mich
-, Dora, 10, b. Mich
-, Harry, 8, b. Mich
-, Clara, 6, b. Ohio
-, Rose B., 1, b. Ohio
Selby, Abby, 17, b. Ohio, at home
Price, Jackson, 45, b Ohio, hack driver
Mathews, Marsh, 23, b. Ohio, blacksmith
Frew, Arthur T., 19, b. Ohio, works in cheese factory
Featon, Emanuel, 21, b. Ohio, works in cheese factory
Trew, John M., 27, b. Ohio
Remalin, Mary, 25, b Ohio

1873 Mar 26 marriage application, Trumbull Co, Ohio
Franklin F. Carlile, b. Newton Falls, Ohio
to
Abbie Selby, b. Newton Falls, Ohio
application made by A. J. Carlile, father of Franklin, because Franklin was only 20, stated he approves

1880 Census, Kent, Portage, Ohio
Carlile, Frank., 28
-, Abbie, 28
-, William, 6
-, Lewis, 4
-, Nathaniel, 4
-, Derwin, 8 [b. Newton Falls, Oh]

1893 Aug 11 birth, Franklin Twp
Donald Carlile
father F. F. Carlile, mother Abbie Selby

1900 Census, Kent, Portage, Ohio
Carlile, Chas F., 47, b. Ohio, parents b. Ohio, plumber
-, Abbie E., 46, b. Apr 1854, Ohio, father b. Conn, mother b. Ohio, m13yrs, 9 children 9 living
-, Derwin F., 27 [Derwin Freeman, b. 1873, d. 1951 Ohio]
-, Lewis, 23
-, Nathanel, 21
-, Arthur, 20
-, Fred, 18 [m. Jeanette Marshall 1905 in Summit Co, Akron]
-, J., 12
-, Donald, 7

1900 Sept 5, marriage, Portage Co
D. F. Carlile, b. 1873 Newton Falls, Oh, father Carlile, mother Abby Silby
to
May A. Donaghy, 25, b. 1875 Coburn, Canada, father Wm H Donaghy, mother Eunice A. Chapin

1910 Census, Franklin, Portage, Ohio
Carlile, Abbie E., 56, wd, b. Ohio
-, Lewis, 32
-, Jay, 21
-, Donald W., 16

1923 Oct 2 death Kent, Portage, Ohio
Abigail Carlile
112 College Dr, 69, widowed
b. 14 Apr 1854, Paris, Ohio
father Wm Selby, b. Ohio
mother Elizabeth Hill, b. Ohio
spouse Frank Carlile

Family search tree listed Abigail Eliza Selby, parents William R. Selby (1825-bef1857) and Elizabeth Loveless (b. 1825 Aug 23 Wood Co Ohio, d. 1915 Dec 9 Snohomish Co Wash) m2. John F. Hill